![]() |
Parliamentary Debates 1998 |
| Adjournment
Debate Matters. An Ceann Comhairle: I wish to advise the House of the following matters in respect of which notice has been given under Standing Order 21 and the name of the Member in each case: (1) Deputy Creed - the urgent need for Údaras na Gaeltacht to secure a new industry for the vacant factory space in Ballingeary, Co. Cork; (2) Deputy McGennis - the up-to-date position regarding the provision of independent counsel to represent rape victims at criminal trials, the legislative or other changes necessary to implement this measure and the probable time scale; (3) Deputy Ring - the plans, if any, the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform has to regulate or prevent public demonstrations on the main streets in Dublin and whether a section of Phoenix Park could be used instead; (4) Deputy Gormley - the need to improve standards of air quality in the light of the admission by the Minister for State at the Department of the Environment and Local Government that Ireland will have difficulty meeting such standards because of increasing traffic levels; (5) Deputy Gilmore - the agreement announced by the Taoiseach and Tánaiste on 8 March which led to the suspension of industrial action by Ryanair workers, especially in the light of the decision by Ryanair to terminate the employment of three baggage handlers, and the need for ministerial intervention to ensure that the agreement is honoured by company management; (6) Deputy Upton -the unacceptable delays in the construction of a physical education hall for a school in Dublin 6W (details supplied); (7) Deputy Michael Kitt - the provision of "step down" accommodation at the Bon Secours Hospital, Tuam, County Galway. The matters raised by Deputies Gilmore, Michael Kitt, Creed and Upton have been selected for discussion. |
| Mrs. Owen:
I congratulate the two new Deputies. I welcome Deputy Jan
O'Sullivan to the House for the first time and wish her
well. As Minister, I remember her making many incisive
interventions in debates in the Seanad. I have no doubt,
therefore, that she will grace this House with her
presence. This is a good day for women. The candidates who finished first, second and third in Limerick East were women. This will help to redress the gender imbalance. We lost some of our number in the last general election. I pay tribute to my party's fine candidate, Mary Jackman, who nearly made it. I welcome back my friend, Deputy Seán Ryan. Those of us who have worked with him in Dublin North know how diligently he works for his constituents. Now that he is back in the Dáil he will keep us on our toes. This is also a great day for the families of Deputies O'Sullivan and Ryan, although there is a sense of poignancy about the proceedings. Shortly we will pay tribute to the memory of a late Member. This is a sign of the strength of our democracy and that life goes on. I wish both Deputies a full and fruitful career in the House. Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Miss Harney): I join the Taoiseach and Deputy Owen in welcoming back to the Dáil Deputy Seán Ryan with whom I have spoken on many occasions in the other House in recent months. I know how much he missed being here. By any standard, he is a hard working public representative and I have no doubt he will apply the same vigour to the task ahead as he did on a previous occasion. I welcome Deputy Jan O'Sullivan to Dáil Éireann, although she is not a newcomer to the Oireachtas. I am delighted the people of Limerick have elected their first woman Deputy. It is extraordinary that so many parts of the country have still to elect their first female Deputies. I wish Deputy O'Sullivan well in the task ahead. She has four male colleagues to contend with - Deputies Noonan, O'Dea, Wade and O'Malley. I am sure she will be well able for them. Mr. Howlin: Hear, hear. Miss Harney: I know they have represented the female gender well in recent years but I am sure they are delighted there is a more even gender balance in Limerick East. As Deputy Owen said, this is a great day for the families of Deputies O'Sullivan and Ryan. It is a privilege and an honour to be elected to serve in this House. It is not a privilege bestowed on everybody. Those on whom it is bestowed should respect it for what it is. Proinsias De Rossa: I welcome wholeheartedly Deputies Jan O'Sullivan and Seán Ryan. It is a great day for the Labour Party to have two new Deputies elected in by-elections. It is a sign of the strength of independence of mind of the electorate that they are prepared to elect Deputies of high calibre to this House in by-elections regardless of their normal voting patterns. This is a growing feature of Irish politics. Long may it last. I have no doubt Deputies O'Sullivan and Ryan will make excellent Deputies. Deputy Ryan proved this on a previous occasion while Deputy O'Sullivan has proved her worth in the Seanad. Long may they remain in the House. Mr. Sargent: Ba mhaith liomsa chomh maith fáilte a chur roimh an bheirt Teachta Dála. Although one could describe Deputy Jan O'Sullivan as a new Deputy, she is renowned as a former Senator and mayor of Limerick. I know her as a person who speaks out on various issues a trait for which she is to be admired and commended. It is not always easy, comfortable or popular to do so. On behalf of the Green Party, I welcome her to the House. I extend a wholehearted welcome to my constituency colleague, Deputy Seán Ryan. Although this may sound strange coming from a rival, I shared his disappointment at his failure to win a seat in the general election following which photograph appeared on the front page of our local newspaper, The Fingal Independent under which it was stated that Deputy Ryan was congratulating me. The fact is I was commiserating with him in a heartfelt way on being pipped for the seat. It is important that I put the record straight. I also congratulate my constituency colleague, Paul Martin, on his forthright performance as a first time candidate and Eric Shepherd in Limerick East. Mr. Wade: I congratulate Deputies Seán Ryan and Jan O'Sullivan. I welcome Deputy O'Sullivan to the House. We have been friends for many years. She is a former member of Limerick Corporation and was an excellent mayor of the city. I wish her many happy years as a Dáil Deputy. I also congratulate the other candidates who stood in Limerick East on the manner in which they conducted their campaigns. I pledge to work with Deputy O'Sullivan and the other constituency representatives for the betterment of Limerick East in the way the late Jim Kemmy did. Caoimhghin Ó Caoláin: Ba mhaith liomsa freisin mo chomhgháirdeachas a ghabháil le Jan agus Sean as an bua íontach a bhí acu sna fothogháin I join my colleagues in tendering my congratulations to Deputy O'Sullivan and Deputy Seán Ryan on their excellent performance and success in the recent by-elections in Limerick East and Dublin North. This is a particularly important day for the Labour Party and it has every right to enjoy its success. I commiserate with all those who contested both by-elections, particularly my two colleagues, Ms Jenny Shapland and Mr. Paul Donnelly, to whom I extend good wishes. I hope I will have the opportunity on a future occasion to be joined in my lonely pursuit in the House. Mr. Rabbitte: I welcome Deputy O'Dea back to the House. Mr. O'Dea: I commiserate with Deputy Rabbitte on the failure of Democratic Left again in Limerick East. I extend my congratulations to the two new Deputies whom I know extremely well. Deputy O'Sullivan has worked long and hard for the people of Limerick and her success is richly deserved. I wish her many years of it. Mr. Dukes: Not a word for Gerry Collins. Mr. Noonan: I congratulate Deputy Seán Ryan and particularly Deputy O'Sullivan. I wish her every success in following in the late Jim Kemmy's footsteps. I hope she has a successful career here. She had an introduction in the Seanad where she was successful and I have no doubt she will help us all to represent the people of Limerick in Dáil Éireann. |
| Mr. Howlin:
It was said in recent days that the best way of
having one's worth recognised in this country is to die.
Many tributes were paid to Hugh Coveney from all
political quarters in recent days. The shock of his
sudden death receded and the recognition dawned on all of
us of the loss to public and political life of Hugh's
passing. More than ever before we have a sense of the
worth of that wonderful parliamentarian. On behalf of the
Labour Party, I express our sympathy to the Fine Gael
Party and most especially to Hugh Coveney's family.
Hugh's death is an immeasurable loss to Pauline, the boys
and his daughter. As someone who worked with him in Government, I found he had an extraordinary ability to work with people from every political persuasion. His passing has evoked an almost unique sense of rallying across the political spectrum. In Cabinet he had an ambitious work programme. He had a tremendous enthusiasm for the Department of the Marine, in particular, and the Department of Defence. He was well able to negotiate his stand. I remember in relation to Structural Funds when he and I were in two separate Departments bidding for money for roads in my case and ports in his, he did rather well and the final proposal accepted by Government was much more generous to the Marine than the original one. That was a measure of the tact he brought to bear on the important work he had. As the Taoiseach said, he was an accomplished yachtsman and represented this country at international level. I know he brought that passion for the sea to Cabinet and, coming from a marine county, I know he endeared himself in a rather unique way to those who live in our coastal communities. They had an extraordinary high regard for him and a great understanding of what he achieved in a relatively short period of time in steering that Ministry. As a Minister of State in the Department of Finance, he worked to ensure that the benefits of a growing economy of additional wealth was shared equally within our community. Given the very difficult task, one of which the Taoiseach will be aware, of negotiating bilaterals with Ministers who are ever anxious to spend more, Hugh brought an extraordinary tact to that job, ensuring there was fairness, understanding and very few rows. He was at the prime of his political and family life. He had so much more to offer public and political life and it is nothing short of a monumental tragedy that his life was cut short in this way. On behalf of the Labour Party, I most sincerely offer my condolences to the Coveney family and hope the tremendous outpouring of grief will be of some comfort to them following this terrible loss. Tánaiste and Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment (Miss Harney): I join the Taoiseach and Deputies Owen and Howlin in expressing my sympathy and that of the Progressive Democrats Party to the late Hugh Coveney's widow, Pauline, his family and the Fine Gael Party. When most of us learnt of his sudden death - in my case early on 15 March - we were deeply shocked that a person we had grown to know and admire could die in such tragic circumstances. I recall on one occasion when I was under pressure Hugh Coveney crossed the floor of the House before a debate to wish me well and offer moral and personal support. I might have been normally surprised to receive support from an unusual quarter but not from him because he was a genuine person and decency shone through in everything he did. He detested adversarial politics, he despised partisan politics and was no prisoner to them. I recall he made mild criticisms of a budget in which his party was involved and, equally, he praised one in which alternative parties were involved. That was the kind of person he was. He was a very gentle person and very shy as Deputy Owen said. He was a busy and successful businessman, an accomplished sportsman and a happy family man. In such circumstances many people would not enter politics but as Peter Barry said the ideal of public service motivated Hugh Coveney. He loved Cork city and county and its people. During the 1994 by-election, I met many people who said they supported party x or party y but were voting for Hugh Coveney. He was highly respected and admired. Last year we held a tribute to Pearse Wyse in Cork on a Wednesday evening and Hugh Coveney came down from the Northern Ireland talks to be in attendance and returned the following morning. He did not mind going out of his way to pay tribute to a political opponent. He was a great ambassador for Fine Gael and politics and was the type of politician who gave politics a good name. We are diminished by his passing as he was a gentleman in every sense. He was a stylish, kind, courteous person on all occasions. I recall my last conversation with him when we spoke about the economy, the taxation system and about how difficult it was on occasion to get people of calibre to enter politics because of the invasion of privacy, etc. We had a long conversation and had a great deal in common on these issues. I had the privilege of meeting some of his seven wonderful children earlier. Our loss is nothing in comparison with theirs and his wife, Pauline. We understand and sympathise with them. It is significant that he died when his children were taking his boat around the world to raise money for Chernobyl. That sums up the kind of person we are talking about. We have lost a politician of substance who had very strong views, but notwithstanding them, he was never afraid to listen to an alternative point of view. In his death, I hope we learn something and his legacy is that perhaps we should be more supportive of each other on occasions as sometimes the adversarial system takes over to too great an extent. It did not in the case of Hugh Coveney who had friends all around the House. We greatly admired and respected him and I hope his family know and understand that. Proinsias De Rossa: Like everybody else in the House, it was with a sense of shocked disbelief that I heard first that Hugh was missing and then that he had been found dead. Nothing we can say will help to ease the pain his wife and children feel but I hope in time the regard he is held in will help. He is a loss to the House and Irish politics. He was a man with enormous qualities who was sensitive, generous and open. I like to think in the time that I got to know him not only did I learn from him but that he picked up some sense of what I was about. I came to regard him as a good friend. He played a significant role in putting the rainbow Government together and argued strongly for the inclusion of Democratic Left because he recognised all politicians in the House have a role to play and there is no reason anyone should be excluded from Government. He also played an enormous role in keeping that Government together through his openness, generosity and his willingness to listen to other points of view and take them on board, as the Tánaiste said. In many respects, we came from opposites poles on the political spectrum but we also found a common purpose. He was driven by a sense of public service and saw how that might delivered through his politics and I through mine. The House, Irish politics, his wife, Pauline, and his children have suffered a grievous loss and the way in which he was taken from them makes it an even deeper one but I hope the sense of loss will be eased and the great respect in which he was held will help. Mr. Sargent: On behalf of the Green Party, I wish to be associated with the expressions of sympathy on the sad, untimely and tragic death of Hugh Coveney. My party was not represented when he first served in the House. Between his first election and his return in 1994 politics had changed as more parties had entered the fray and issues had also changed but it seems whatever changes occurred, they did not change Hugh Coveney who had clear ideas about politics and how they should be practised. It was this consistent gentlemanly approach that has been most commented upon since his death. A mutual friend, Adi Roche, also asked me to pass on expressions of sympathy given the fantastic work his family was doing for the Chernobyl Children's Project. She said the innocent victims of Chernobyl have lost a dear and generous friend in the tragic death of Hugh Coveney. He was one of the most generous spirited men she ever knew, always giving generously of his time and energy. I felt there was hope for our fishing communities and the marine environment generally when Hugh Coveney was Minister for Defence and the Marine. Many fishermen, sailors, and members of the Defence Forces feel that a light has gone out on their hopes for the future. In the intense goldfish bowl world that is modern politics we all could learn from Hugh Coveney how to appreciate the truly important things in life, for instance one's family. The notion of public life as public service is an important ideal which Hugh Coveney lived to the fullest. He had been successful in practically every other aspect of life and had no need to enter public life to enhance his self image. He could have walked away at the times when the electorate told him that others, not him, would serve them. It was this quality of service which made him something of an enigma. While most politicians are paranoid about their future, Hugh Coveney always gave the impression that it was an honour to serve and that other elements of his life, particularly his family, had an even greater importance. It is they more than anyone who will miss him most. God bless them. Ar dheis Dé go raibh a anam uasal. Minister for Education and Science (Mr. Martin): As a constituency colleague of the late Hugh Coveney, I extend sympathy to his family. The people of Cork have still not come to terms with the loss of Hugh Coveney. There is an air of disbelief on the streets that our beloved city has lost such a distinguished political and sporting son. The thousands of people who lined the streets of Cork for the removal and Mass was a very eloquent testimony to the very high esteem in which Hugh Coveney was held. Never before was there such an outpouring across all shades of opinion in Cork as there was at the loss of this wonderful person. His abiding characteristics were gentleness, kindness and courtesy. He always wanted to affirm the good in people. He was not one to detract or undermine. Never for him the cheap political gibe or publicity stunt. He never deliberately tried to trip someone up in the conduct of his duty. Rather he was anxious to tell a person of the good things and encourage them to press ahead with the initiatives in which they were engaged. Obviously he had a tremendous interest in Cork and in the advancement of projects there. This stemmed from his commitment to the business and industrial life of Cork. His love affair with the people of Cork began during his time as a dynamic and distinguished Lord Mayor of the city. He and his wife Pauline were a distinguished couple and their mayoralty of Cork left a lasting impression on the public mindset. He was a very frank individual. The first time I learned that Fianna Fáil had a chance of winning three seats in Cork South-Central during the last general election was when Hugh confided to me three months previously that his opinion polls pointed in this direction. During the election campaign he deliberately tried to reduce his vote. He would unquestionably have won 12,000 or 13,000 votes but he was anxious to get the right result for the Fine Gael Party. He did this most admirably. He was a unique politician. As I have stated on the public airwaves, if an eager beaver young politician arrived at a church to hand out cards Hugh, calmly and with a smile on his face, would offer to move on to the next church. The representatives of Cork South-Central will miss him as he set the tone in terms of how we behave towards one another and the relationships we enjoy. Those of us who attended the funeral ceremony will remember the wonderful nobility and courage of his family in their tributes to him. In their eloquent contributions they showed what a wonderful family man he was. The love for him which shone through that ceremony will long be remembered in the city of Cork. Ms Clune: I welcome the opportunity to pay tribute to my former party and constituency colleague, Hugh Coveney. The extent to which Hugh Coveney was respected is evident from the many tributes paid to him today and during the past week. I knew Hugh since I was a child as a neighbour and family friend and it was only in the 1994 by-election that I became involved in his political career. We were both elected last year to represent Cork South-Central on behalf of Fine Gael. That was a very proud day for me. I had a very supportive colleague in Hugh Coveney and many of my colleagues in all parties envied the help he gave me over the past six months. The people of Cork miss Hugh Coveney and mourn his loss. However, the greatest loss is for Pauline and his family who have lost a husband, father and friend. They gained much from him and had some good times, but not enough. Hugh was everybody's friend. Everyone felt they could approach him. No matter how trivial the request, he was always available and courteous. As a Front Bench spokesperson he was always very helpful to new Deputies. Hugh was open and straightforward. He had no hidden agenda; what one saw was what one got. He had a wonderful sense of public service. He was elected to do a job and he did it in an efficient and businesslike manner. He had great confidence in his own abilities and did not need to react to others, to undermine them or to make personal attacks for political gain. He had the confidence and sense of right to do things his way. Hugh Coveney portrayed what people want of politicians, to get on with the business of representing them. This was evident in the huge vote he received in Cork South-Central last June. As the Minister, Deputy Martin said, his vote would have been much higher if he had not focused on trying to increase Fine Gael's representation in the city. Those of us elected to the House last June and since should never forget Hugh Coveney. We should always carry with us his true sense of public service. Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin: Ba mhaith liom mó chomhbhrón a gabháil chuige muintir Coveney ar bás é. I join other Members in paying tribute to the memory of the late Hugh Coveney. I extend my sympathy and that of my party to his wife and family on their tragic loss. During my short time as a Member I regrettably only had a few occasions to speak with Hugh Coveney. On each occasion I had that pleasure I knew I was speaking with someone who was sincere and interested. We shared an interest in the unfolding events in the peace process, an issue he broached with me on a number of occasions. He struck me as a person of great character. He showed an interest and was very much a representative of all the people who elected him to this House. His family has undoubtedly suffered the greatest loss, but I also extend my sympathy to his party colleagues. Hugh Coveney was public spirited and interested in serving not only his constituency but also his country and his loss is felt by his family, party and all those who view this island as home. Ar dheis lámh Dé go raibh a anam dílis. Mr. L. Burke: Hugh Coveney was one of the finest people I knew. He was a kind, gentle and unassuming man. His simplicity was greatly admired not only by the people of Cork but by all the people. He was a great listener and compromiser. He was a class act and a breed apart and his contribution to the commercial and public life of Cork is unprecedented. He was president of the Cork Chamber of Commerce and a member of the Cork Harbour Commissioners. He was elected to Cork Corporation as an alderman in 1979, was Lord Mayor from 1982 to 1983 and was first elected to Dáil Éireann in 1981. He was greatly admired not only by me but by the people of Cork and his death is a terrible blow not only to Cork but to Ireland. He is a great loss to the Fine Gael Party in Cork and to his wife Pauline, his six sons and one daughter. I am glad to see two of his sons, Simon and Rory, in the Gallery. I extend my deepest sympathy to his family and may God grant him eternal rest. Members rose |